| Club | Player | Age | Drafted | Games | B&F Wins |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Adelaide | Bernie Vince | 23 | #32 National 2005 | 24 (55) | 1 |
| Brisbane | Jonathan Brown | 27 | #30 National 1999 | 24 (184) | 3 |
| Carlton | Chris Judd | 25 | #3 National 2001 | 23 (178) | 4 |
| Collingwood | Dane Swan | 24 | #58 National 2001 | 25 (125) | 2 |
| Essendon | Jobe Watson | 23 | #40 National 2002 | 22 (94) | 1 |
| Fremantle | Aaron Sandilands | 26 | #33 Rookie 2001 | 20 (135) | 1 |
| Geelong | Gary Ablett | 24 | #40 National 2001 | 22 (168) | 2 |
| Geelong | Corey Enright | 27 | #47 National 1999 | 25 (175) | 1 |
| Hawthorn | Sam Mitchell | 26 | #36 National 2001 | 22 (155) | 2 |
| Melbourne | Aaron Davey | 25 | #3 Rookie 2003 | 22 (119) | 1 |
| North Melbourne | Andrew Swallow | 21 | #43 National 2005 | 22 (62) | 1 |
| Port Adelaide | Warren Tredrea | 30 | Foundation 1996 | 21 (248) | 4 |
| Richmond | Brett Deledio | 21 | #1 National 2004 | 22 (106) | 2 |
| St Kilda | Nick Riewoldt | 26 | #1 National 2000 | 24 (182) | 5 |
| Sydney | Ryan O'Keefe | 27 | #56 National 1999 | 22 (186) | 1 |
| West Coast | Darren Glass | 27 | #11 National 1999 | 22 (188) | 2 |
| Western Bulldogs | Matthew Boyd | 26 | #23 Rookie 2001 | 25 (140) | 1 |