| Club | Player | Age | Drafted | Games | B&F Wins |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Adelaide | Rory Sloane | 22 | #44 National 2008 | 21 (78) | 1 |
| Brisbane | Joel Patfull | 28 | #14 Rookie 2002 | 22 (161) | 2 |
| Carlton | Kade Simpson | 28 | #45 National 2002 | 24 (200) | 1 |
| Collingwood | Scott Pendlebury | 25 | #5 National 2005 | 23 (171) | 2 |
| Essendon | Brendon Goddard | 27 | #1 National 2002 | 22 (227) | 1 |
| Fremantle | Nathan Fyfe | 21 | #20 National 2009 | 22 (72) | 1 |
| Geelong | Joel Selwood | 24 | #7 National 2006 | 25 (160) | 2 |
| Gold Coast | Gary Ablett | 28 | #40 National 2001 | 21 (253) | 5 |
| GWS | Jeremy Cameron | 19 | GWS Underage 2010 | 21 (37) | 1 |
| Hawthorn | Josh Gibson | 28 | #7 Rookie 2004 | 24 (148) | 1 |
| Melbourne | Nathan Jones | 24 | #12 National 2005 | 22 (157) | 2 |
| North Melbourne | Daniel Wells | 27 | #2 National 2002 | 22 (212) | 2 |
| North Melbourne | Scott Thompson | 26 | #37 National 2007 | 19 (112) | 1 |
| Port Adelaide | Chad Wingard | 19 | #6 National 2011 | 24 (43) | 1 |
| Richmond | Daniel Jackson | 26 | #53 National 2003 | 23 (146) | 1 |
| St Kilda | Jack Steven | 22 | #42 National 2007 | 22 (73) | 1 |
| Sydney | Jarrad McVeigh | 27 | #5 National 2002 | 25 (219) | 2 |
| West Coast | Matt Priddis | 27 | #31 Rookie 2005 | 21 (151) | 1 |
| Western Bulldogs | Ryan Griffen | 26 | #3 National 2004 | 20 (183) | 2 |