| Geelong | |||||||||
| What Geelong Gave | What Geelong Got | ||||||||
| Zach Tuohy | 168 games | 54 XG | |||||||
| Billie Smedts | 9 games | 77 XG | |||||||
| Pick 63 | Cameron Polson | 19 games | 112 points | 11 XG | |||||
| 2017R2 (Carlton) (estimate: pick 23) |
Lachlan Fogarty | 70 games | 815 points | 57 XG | |||||
| 2017R1 (Geelong) (estimate: pick 16) |
Zac Bailey | 140 games | 1067 points | 70 XG | |||||
| 2 picks | 1 player | 168 games | 1179 points | 158 XG | 1 pick | 1 player | 238 games | 815 points | 111 XG |
| Carlton | |||||||||
| What Carlton Gave | What Carlton Got | ||||||||
| Zach Tuohy | 168 games | 54 XG | |||||||
| Billie Smedts | 9 games | 77 XG | |||||||
| Pick 63 | Cameron Polson | 19 games | 112 points | 11 XG | |||||
| 2017R1 (Geelong) (estimate: pick 16) |
Pick traded on to another club | 1067 points | 70 XG | ||||||
| 2017R2 (Carlton) (estimate: pick 23) |
Lachlan Fogarty | 70 games | 815 points | 57 XG | |||||
| 1 pick | 1 player | 238 games | 815 points | 111 XG | 2 picks | 1 player | 28 games | 1179 points | 158 XG |