| Melbourne | |||||||||
| What Melbourne Gave | What Melbourne Got | ||||||||
| Chris Dawes | 50 games | 77 XG | |||||||
| Pick 20 | Tim Broomhead | 37 games | 912 points | 66 XG | |||||
| Pick 45 | Mitchell Wilkins | 0 games | 347 points | 20 XG | |||||
| Pick 58 | Pick traded on to another club | 170 points | 11 XG | ||||||
| 2 picks | 0 players | 37 games | 1259 points | 86 XG | 1 pick | 1 player | 50 games | 170 points | 88 XG |
| Collingwood | |||||||||
| What Collingwood Gave | What Collingwood Got | ||||||||
| Chris Dawes | 50 games | 77 XG | |||||||
| Pick 20 | Tim Broomhead | 37 games | 912 points | 66 XG | |||||
| Pick 45 | Pick traded on to another club | 347 points | 20 XG | ||||||
| Pick 58 | Taylor Hine | 14 games | 170 points | 11 XG | |||||
| 1 pick | 1 player | 64 games | 170 points | 88 XG | 2 picks | 0 players | 37 games | 1259 points | 86 XG |