| Melbourne | |||||||||
| What Melbourne Gave | What Melbourne Got | ||||||||
| Kyle Cheney | 71 games | 22 XG | |||||||
| Pick 52 | Tom McDonald | 232 games | 246 points | 14 XG | |||||
| Pick 66 | Paul Puopolo | 196 games | 80 points | 10 XG | |||||
| 1 pick | 1 player | 267 games | 80 points | 32 XG | 1 pick | 0 players | 232 games | 246 points | 14 XG |
| Hawthorn | |||||||||
| What Hawthorn Gave | What Hawthorn Got | ||||||||
| Kyle Cheney | 27 games | 22 XG | |||||||
| Pick 52 | Tom McDonald | 232 games | 246 points | 14 XG | |||||
| Pick 66 | Paul Puopolo | 196 games | 80 points | 10 XG | |||||
| 1 pick | 0 players | 232 games | 246 points | 14 XG | 1 pick | 1 player | 223 games | 80 points | 32 XG |