| Carlton | |||||||||
| What Carlton Gave | What Carlton Got | ||||||||
| Mick McGuane | 3 games | 23 XG | |||||||
| Pick 19 | Brent Tuckey | 22 games | 948 points | 63 XG | |||||
| Pick 65 | Brad Cassidy | 2 games | 90 points | 11 XG | |||||
| 2 picks | 0 players | 24 games | 1038 points | 74 XG | 0 picks | 1 player | 3 games | 0 points | 23 XG |
| Collingwood | |||||||||
| What Collingwood Gave | What Collingwood Got | ||||||||
| Mick McGuane | 3 games | 23 XG | |||||||
| Pick 19 | Brent Tuckey | 22 games | 948 points | 63 XG | |||||
| Pick 65 | Brad Cassidy | 2 games | 90 points | 11 XG | |||||
| 0 picks | 1 player | 3 games | 0 points | 23 XG | 2 picks | 0 players | 24 games | 1038 points | 74 XG |