| Club | Player | Age | Drafted | Games | B&F Wins |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Adelaide | Rory Laird | 24 | #5 Rookie 2011 | 20 (121) | 1 |
| Brisbane | Dayne Zorko | 28 | Prelist 2011 | 22 (144) | 4 |
| Carlton | Patrick Cripps | 22 | #13 National 2013 | 22 (81) | 2 |
| Collingwood | Brodie Grundy | 23 | #18 National 2012 | 26 (108) | 1 |
| Collingwood | Steele Sidebottom | 27 | #11 National 2008 | 26 (211) | 2 |
| Essendon | Devon Smith | 24 | #14 National 2011 | 22 (131) | 1 |
| Fremantle | Lachie Neale | 24 | #58 National 2011 | 22 (135) | 2 |
| Geelong | Mark Blicavs | 26 | #54 Rookie 2011 | 23 (133) | 2 |
| Gold Coast | Jarrod Harbrow | 29 | #27 Rookie 2006 | 22 (224) | 1 |
| GWS | Lachie Whitfield | 23 | #1 National 2012 | 24 (114) | 1 |
| Hawthorn | Tom Mitchell | 24 | #21 National 2011 | 24 (111) | 2 |
| Melbourne | Max Gawn | 26 | #34 National 2009 | 25 (99) | 1 |
| North Melbourne | Shaun Higgins | 29 | #11 National 2005 | 20 (203) | 2 |
| Port Adelaide | Justin Westhoff | 31 | #71 National 2006 | 22 (248) | 1 |
| Richmond | Jack Riewoldt | 29 | #13 National 2006 | 24 (249) | 2 |
| St Kilda | Jack Steven | 27 | #42 National 2007 | 22 (176) | 4 |
| Sydney | Jake Lloyd | 24 | #16 Rookie 2012 | 23 (115) | 1 |
| West Coast | Elliot Yeo | 24 | #30 National 2011 | 25 (132) | 2 |
| Western Bulldogs | Lachie Hunter | 23 | #49 National 2012 | 21 (105) | 1 |